Halloween Mystery Box | PLEASE READ EVERYTHING

Halloween Mystery Box | PLEASE READ EVERYTHING


Ask a question


You guys message about the Halloween mystery boxes year round and I am excited to announce they're back! These will only be available for purchase until 9/16 or until they sell out and every mystery box will be shipped by 10/3.

Please follow these steps to make sure your box is perfectly customized for you:

1. Select the material and box size from the dropdown. Boxes are available in one, two, or three rings with extra goodies inside. The bigger the box the more extras you will receive!

2. Copy the following questions and paste/answer in the order notes or a message through the site. The order notes are located on the page after entering your payment info. Please do not send these via Instagram. Without your response to these questions your order may be cancelled or delayed. Not every question will apply to every box size.

-What size ring do you wear?
-Which Trash Cat pieces do you currently own (feel free to send a photo if needed)?
-How do you describe your style?
-Do you wear earrings?
-What is your favorite part of Halloween (be as thorough as you'd like, the more info the better
and I LOVE getting to know you guys through these)?

3. You are all finished! Follow @trashcatcollective on Instagram for updates!

Shipping from United States

Processing time

1-4 weeks

Estimated shipping times

  • North America : 3 - 7 business days

I'll do my best to meet these shipping estimates, but can't guarantee them. Actual delivery time will depend on the shipping method you choose.

Customs and import taxes

Buyers are responsible for any customs and import taxes that may apply. I'm not responsible for delays due to customs.

Payment Options

Secure options
  • Accepts Etsy gift cards

Returns & Exchanges

I gladly accept returns, exchanges, and cancellations

Just contact me within: 7 days of delivery

Ship items back to me within: 14 days of delivery

Request a cancellation within: 12 hours of purchase

But please contact me if you have any problems with your order.

The following items can't be returned or exchanged

Because of the nature of these items, unless they arrive damaged or defective, I can't accept returns for:

  • Custom or personalized orders
  • Perishable products (like food or flowers)

Conditions of return

Buyers are responsible for return shipping costs. If the item is not returned in its original condition, the buyer is responsible for any loss in value.

Questions about your order?

Please contact me if you have any problems with your order.

Frequently Asked Questions

Wholesale availability

To inquire about wholesale pricing please contact thetrashcat@yahoo.com

Care instructions

Your jewelry is finished with a water proof sealant before it ships. Over time the sealant may wear off and need additional polishing/resealing. Some ways to keep your jewelry looking sparkly and new include:

-Do not store your jewelry in a humid area such as a bathroom

-If you live in a humid climate consider storing your jewelry in an enclosed case, bag, or box to preserve the shine

-Avoid water, hand sanitizer, and chemicals as much as possible

-You can polish your jewelry easily with a polishing pad (available as an add-on) to make it look new again or if you are in a bind ketchup is commonly used. Just submerge your jewelry and buff off.

-A common home remedy to lacquer jewelry is clear nail polish

-You can always contact me

Sizing details

For sizing your fingers I definitely recommend consulting a local jeweler or purchasing a cheap ring sizer online. If you are unable to size your fingers as mentioned here are some other considerations:

The most common sizes I sell are
6 (slightly smaller than average)
7 (average)
8 (slightly larger than average)

If your fingers are very thin your size may run from 4-5
If your fingers are larger you may consider a 9-10
For men's sizing you can typically add two sizes.

You can also cut off the sticky part of a post-it note and wrap around your finger, marking where the ends meet. Measuring the post-it note in mm and converting (or messaging me) should give you a pretty accurate size.

Gift wrapping and packaging

Standard packaging for rings include a plastic capsule filled with styrofoam confetti in a hand-printed bubble mailer.

Standard packaging for necklaces include a hand stamped card-stock tag in a clear plastic protective sleeve that is shipped in a hand-printed bubble mailer.

Also available upon request (in your order notes) are hand stamped gift boxes.

For bridal parties or events feel free to message me about custom packaging for your order.

Will brass turn my fingers green?

There are many factors that affect metal such as hormones, sodium levels, and personal allergies. For that reason I can not confidently say that the brass will not turn your finger green. With that being said, it is more common that people have no reaction for the following reasons.

Brass does contain a small amount of nickel (which turns your fingers green). While I am heating the metal a lot of the nickel comes to the surface and is removed in the polishing phase. Additionally your jewelry is sealed with a water-proof wax that serves as a barrier from your skin and protects the shine of your piece.

If you are concerned about an allergy to brass you may consider sterling silver which very rarely causes a reaction.

Reviews (3)


I know this is a once a year thing, but Caitlin is amazing! The pieces are exactly my style, and she included a handwritten note (which I imagine she does with every order)! I honestly can’t believe these are homemade, her talent is unbelievable. Not to mention the creativity! Stop buying rings from Urban or Anthro—start supporting this lovely person! She’s so easy to work with and you can tell she wants to provide customers with pieces she knows they’ll enjoy. Simply amazing. ✨❤️ Plus the pricing?! A *steal* for handmade pieces.

I cannot express how much I love the rings I received in the Halloween mystery box! This is my second time ordering from Trash Cat and I can’t wait to order more. Also my cat Teddy says thank you for his toy.

This is my favorite store on here she always exceeds my expectations